Build or Buy Shaker Cabinet Doors: A Real 12-Door Cost Breakdown

Build or Buy Shaker Cabinet Doors: A Real 12-Door Cost Breakdown - A step into the workshop.
Stop Wasting Wood
Generate clear cut diagrams instantly with our new Cutlist Optimizer. Plan your cuts to make your next build easier.
I price a lot of doors before I ever cut one. Not because I like spreadsheets, but because the most expensive mistake in a cabinet job is discovering, halfway through, that the doors you decided to build have quietly eaten the margin on the whole kitchen. A client asks for shaker doors, I sketch the layout, and there are twelve of them. The question that follows isn't "build or buy?" It's "at what total cost, and which side do I control?"
So I work the twelve doors three ways: shop-built rail-and-stile, shop-built slab, and ordered. Each way, I price the whole door — the material, the labor, the finish, and the hinge drilling — because a per-door list price or a board-foot number tells you almost nothing on its own. Below is the arithmetic, laid out so you can drop in your own shop's numbers. None of these totals is a quote; they're what falls out of the inputs once you write them down.
First, the size trap
Example door: 12" by 30" is 2.5 square feet. Cabinet door pricing, whether you build or buy, is dominated by how the supplier bills — and the two you're most likely to meet bill differently.
Cutting Edge (a Canadian custom-door manufacturer) prices maple shaker doors with plywood panels at $29 per square foot with a $43 per-piece minimum, because the minimum billed area is 1.5 square feet. Custom MDF USA prices an unfinished slab door at $9 per square foot plus a $7 per-piece fee; painted slab runs $30 per square foot plus $17 per piece. That per-piece fee is small on a big door and large on a small one. Custom MDF's own worked example puts a 12"×30" upper at roughly $30–$40 unfinished and $92–$100 fully painted. Note that range comes with all its asterisks — that's the manufacturer's own estimate, not a bid.
A twelve-door kitchen isn't twelve identical doors, but for clean comparison I use a uniform 2.5-square-foot door and scale at the end. If your kitchen runs large doors, per-square-foot math is kinder; if it's twelve small uppers, the per-piece minimums and fees will bite. Price your actual sizes.
The ordered door, all-in
Start with Cutting Edge, because its price list is the most explicit about what's excluded. A maple shaker with a plywood center panel is $29/square foot. A 2.5-square-foot door bills at 2.5 sq ft — the $43 minimum assumes 1.5 sq ft, so a 2.5 sq ft door is billed on area — which is $72.50, before any of the excluded work. Doors arrive unfinished, un-drilled, and uncustomized.
What you pay to have Cutting Edge finish them, per Cutting Edge: clear lacquer adds about $15 per square foot; a painted finish adds about $36 per square foot. On a 2.5-square-foot door that's about $37.50 for lacquer or $90 for paint, on top of the $72.50 door. Hinge drilling adds about $1.30 per hole, or about $2.60 for a two-hinge door.
So one ordered, lacquered, hinge-bored Cutting Edge maple shaker door runs roughly $72.50 + $37.50 + $2.60 = about $112.60. Painted instead, roughly $165.10. Those are arithmetic, not quotes, and they carry two caveats. First, Cutting Edge's figures are Canadian retail pricing; the pages don't state a conversion, so don't assume these are US dollars. Second, Cutting Edge's finishing numbers are internally inconsistent — the solid-wood page states clear lacquer at about $15/sq ft while a summary table on the same page frames finishing as "at least $23 per piece," and the maple page says finishing takes the door to "at least $45 per square foot." I'm using the $15 and $36 adders as the per-square-foot estimates they appear to be, but you should price the specific door you're ordering.
Custom MDF gives a second, lower anchor on the slab side. A painted slab at $30/sq ft plus $17/piece: $75 + $17 = $92 per door, before the $4.50-per-hole hinge boring it bills separately (about $9 for two hinges). That's for MDF with a factory finish, not wood.
The shop-built door, before you touch a board
The build side starts with lumber and labor, and both are ranges.
Verified lumber: Ocooch Hardwoods sells 13/16" S2S hard maple at $5.80 per board foot, 10 bd ft minimum, and tells you to plan for 10%–20% waste on rough-edge random-width stock. There's no verified retail price in my sources for poplar, cherry, walnut, or white oak, and no verified price for 1/4" plywood panels, so I'm keeping the lumber math on hard maple and treating the panel cost as the unknown I'd fill in at the counter.
The labor is. CabinetBoost derives a loaded shop cost of $45–$65 per billable hour — a $21.44/hr average cabinet maker wage (PayScale) plus FICA, SUTA/FUTA, workers' comp under NCCI class code 2802 (CabinetBoost notes 4%–10% of payroll typical), 20% non-billable time, and $14–$35/hr overhead. CabinetBoost is explicit that this is a derivation, not a published benchmark; treat it as a defensible model, not a survey result.
Now the time per door, which is the honest heart of this. A 2018 WOODWEB Architectural Woodworking thread on cabinet door production time collected shop owners' own numbers for all-solid cope-and-stick doors: about an hour per door in a one-man shop (including parts figuring), one hour "door only, no hinge pocket, no finish" for another shop with two shapers, 15–18 minutes for a single door solo with tooling set up, about 30 minutes per door in a two-man full production line, and about 12 minutes per door in a production setting. The spread is 12 to 60 minutes, and it matters more than any other number here.
Run the math both ends. At 60 minutes and $45–$65/hr loaded, labor is $45–$65 per door — before lumber, hinges, finish, or a hinge jig. Against Cutting Edge's $72.50 unfinished ordered door, you'd need the material and your time to close a gap that's already gone negative if your hour is really worth $55. At 15 minutes, labor is $11–$16 per door.
That spread isn't really about skill. It's about tooling and batch size. In the WOODWEB posts, the slowest figures came from a one-man shop and from a two-shop setup doing door only, while the fastest came from a set-up production operation and a solo maker with tooling already in place.
The swing item nobody prices: finish
Finishing is where build-vs-buy comparisons quietly die. On the ordered side, Cutting Edge signals it loudly: lacquer adds about $15/sq ft, paint about $36/sq ft. On a $29/sq ft maple door, the paint adder alone more than doubles the unfinished price, and the maple page's alternate framing — finishing taking the door to "at least $45 per square foot" — is still a 55% increase. Whatever your own spray time and booth are worth, finishing is the difference between a $30-ish door and something much closer to $90.
I can't give you a verified materials or labor cost for doing the finish in-house — my sources only give the supplier's adder, not what paint, lacquer, spray equipment, or a booth cost you. What I can tell you is that if you don't have a controlled space to spray, the ordered, pre-finished door carries less risk than the door you finish yourself. If you do have a booth, price your spray hour at your loaded rate and compare honestly, not at a fantasy number.
Hinge drilling: cheap to buy, easy to underestimate
Hinge drilling is the smallest line item and the one most often skipped. Cutting Edge charges about $1.30 per hole, about $2.60 for a two-hinge door. Custom MDF charges $4.50 per hole, billed separately — about $9 for two — because boring is a separate operation. For the hardware itself, CabinetParts.com lists a Blum 38N compact soft-close face-frame hinge with integrated mounting plate at $3.17 each, dropping to $3.07 at 250 pieces. Two hinges is $6.34 in hardware. Note that the drill charge is billing, and the hinge cost is a physical part; they're at different suppliers and not additive as if they came from one place. And note that no verified hinge-jig price exists in my sources, so I won't quote one — but I'd budget for the fact that drilling accurately at a consistent cup depth rewards a real jig.
The verdict, as arithmetic
Put it on the table for the twelve-door kitchen, 2.5 sq ft per door:
| Path | Door cost | Finish | Hinge drilling | Hardware | Loaded lab. (build only) | Per door |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shop-built rail-and-stile, painted | — | yours | yours | $6.34 | $11–$16 (15 min) to $45–$65 (60 min) | before finish |
| Shop-built slab (MDF, painted) | n/a — no verified panel/resin cost | yours | yours | $6.34 | as above | not honestly computable |
| Ordered, Cutting Edge lacquered, bored | $72.50 | ~$37.50 lacquer | $2.60 | $6.34 | — | ~$118.94 all-in |
| Ordered, Custom MDF painted slab, bored | $92 | included | $9.00 | $6.34 | — | ~$107.34 all-in |
The arithmetic says two things I've come to believe in my own shop. First, for a shop carrying real overhead and building a single small order of doors, shop-built is not obviously cheaper than ordered. At the one-hour end, your labor alone is $45–$65 per door against a $72.50 unfinished ordered door, and you still have to finish and drill it. The moment against a finished lacquered door, the build side loses unless your time is at the low end and you're batching. Second, the door that wins on total cost wins because of finishing and setup, not because of board feet or hinge dollars.
If your shop runs twelve doors in a batch with dedicated tooling and a booth, build them. If you're a one-man shop with a shaper you change over twice per part, order them unfinished and finish them yourself, or order them painted if you don't have a controlled spray space. And if you're pricing this for a client, put the total on the page before you commit — the number that matters is the one after finish and drilling, not the one on the door.