What a Board Foot Really Costs: Tally Rules, Surfacing Loss, and Yard Prices

What a Board Foot Really Costs: Tally Rules, Surfacing Loss, and Yard Prices - A step into the workshop.
Stop Wasting Wood
Generate clear cut diagrams instantly with our new Cutlist Optimizer. Plan your cuts to make your next build easier.
Yo, let me tell you a story. There's a guy at the counter arguing about a receipt. He's got one board on the counter. Four-quarter, eleven inches wide, ten feet long. The ticket says 10.6 board feet. He's doing the math on his phone and getting madder by the second.
I've been that guy. You've probably been that guy. So let's talk about what that board foot on the sticker actually buys you, because the number at the top of the price list and the number you should care about are two different numbers.
The Unit Doesn't Care About Your Finished Part
One board foot is 144 cubic inches. Woodworkers Source gives you three formulas to get there: thickness times width times length in inches, divided by 144. Or the same in feet, divided by 12. Or thickness times square feet. All three land in the same place.
Here's the line that matters, straight from Woodworkers Source: thickness uses the rough sawn dimension, not your final net dimension. You are billed on the rough inch. That 4/4 board was an inch thick when it came off the saw. It will not be an inch thick when it goes into your project. You pay for the inch anyway.
Also from Woodworkers Source: anything under an inch thick gets sold by the square foot, not the board foot. That matters when you're pricing a 3/8-inch panel glue-up versus 4/4 stock, because you're comparing two different units and the sticker won't always say so loud.
And because hardwoods come in random widths and lengths, every board in the stack is measured on its own. There's no standard size you can multiply. You measure, you tally, you add.
Rough Versus Surfaced: Where the Footage Goes
A WOODWEB thread from 2012 called "Lumber Tally: Rough Versus Milled" is the best thing I've read on this, and it's got Gene Wengert, the forum's technical advisor, weighing in. The practitioner numbers in there are worth tattooing somewhere.
One contributor says ordering 100 board feet S2S and straightlined nets him about 90 board feet. Call it 10% gone. His supplier tallies the rough footage and doesn't re-tally after milling. Another says 7% is the long-used waste factor for straightline ripping, and that surfacing plus SLR runs about 30 cents a foot. A third buys wholesale on gross tally, paying 8% over net. His example: two dollars a foot actually costs $2.16.
Now the argument that started the thread. That buyer with the eleven-inch board got billed 10.6 board feet because the yard multiplied the footage by 115% "to account for straightlining." His old supplier called it a 15% ripoff. The new yard's manager said it was industry standard.
Wengert did the arithmetic. 4/4 by 11 inches by 10 feet is 9.1666 board feet. Hardwoods round to the closest board foot. It's 9. Not 10.6. And his verdict on the 15%: "The straighten fee of 15% less footage is not an industry standard."
He goes further. Weights and measures divisions in every state and province require you to get the footage you're billed for. Adding footage to account for kiln shrinkage, he says, is illegal, and so is delivering 15% less than billed. If the seller mills the lumber before you own it, they have to recalculate the footage after milling.
Handle this one honestly, though. A wholesale buyer of thirty years reports that of his five suppliers, only one sells kiln-dried lumber net. Gross tally is his world, legal standard or not. So ask. Every time. "Is this net or gross?" is a five-second question that changes the price.
Read the Tally Like You Mean It
The good yards tell you their conventions. Use that.
Kettle Moraine Hardwoods publishes its price list, effective 8/9/2026, and it spells things out. Everything except 3/8-inch stock is priced per board foot based on the rough thickness shown. Some boards in the bins are skip planed, and they still sell at the rough sawn price. That's a real, verifiable example of paying rough money for partly surfaced stock. Their wide-board premium is 25% over listed prices, and wide starts at 11 inches in most species. It drops to 10 inches in birch, butternut, hickory and walnut, and 8 inches in aromatic cedar. That's their rule, not everybody's, so read the sheet in front of you.
Woodworkers Source shows you how the upcharges stack on cherry. Base is $8.99 a board foot for 4/4 S2S Select & Better. Add a dollar a foot for a 5-inch minimum width. Add $1.25 for 6-inch. Add a quarter to straightline rip one edge. Base price is the start of the conversation, not the end.
That same cherry tells you what you're actually getting. It's 4/4 nominal, S2S, actual thickness 13/16 inch, random widths 5 to 10 inches, lengths 6 to 12 feet. The page says you should yield about 3/4 inch after flattening, planing and sanding. So you paid for 4/4 and you're building with 3/4. That gap is your surfacing loss, printed on the listing.
One more disclosure from the same page, and I love it for the honesty: you may receive slightly more wood than you ordered and be charged for it, because quantity depends on what's in the pile. Plan for the invoice to wiggle.
Real Numbers, So You Can Stop Guessing
Here's the spread. All list prices, per board foot, from named suppliers.
Baird Brothers lists 4/4 red oak rough sawn at $5.47, 5/4 at $5.75, 8/4 at $8.32. Kettle Moraine's list has 4/4 knotty alder at $2.74, 4/4 select ash at $3.19, 4/4 aromatic cedar at $5.40, and 8/4 quartersawn African mahogany at $12.74.
Look at that again. "A board foot" covers $2.74 alder and $12.74 mahogany. Saying lumber is expensive is like saying food is expensive. Which food?
And note the 8/4 math. Red oak doubles in thickness from 4/4 to 8/4 and goes from $5.47 to $8.32. That's about 1.5 times the price per board foot, and a board foot is the same volume either way, so the thicker stock costs you more per cubic inch, not less.
The Cost Per Useable Board Foot
Now do the real calculation. Take your base price. Add the milling charge if the yard does it and bills for it. Add the width and edge upcharges. Apply the tally convention: gross, net, or something in between. Then divide by what you'll actually have after surfacing.
A rough, workable set of waste bands: simple builds in high-grade S4S run 5% to 10% waste, while complex builds or lower grades run 30% to 50% or more. That's from the Total Wood Store blog, which attributes the figures to WoodBFCalculator and WOODWEB. Treat it as a secondary summary, not a measured study. The WOODWEB practitioners give you the tighter milling numbers: about 10% on S2S plus straightline, 7% for SLR, 8% gross over net. Those are the ones I'd build a budget on.
Grade belongs in the calculation too. NHLA grades are based on the percentage of clear, defect-free wood on a board, measured as clear cuttings, per the NHLA grading rules summary. Commonly stated figures put FAS at 83.33% to 100% clear and No. 1 Common at 66.67% to 83.33%. Lower grade means more waste, which means a higher cost per useable foot even when the sticker is lower. Cheap board with big defects is not cheap.
One thing that doesn't transfer: the softwood nominal tables. Under the American Softwood Lumber Standard, a nominal 1x4 finishes at 3/4 by 3-1/2, and a 2x4 at 1-1/2 by 3-1/2, per Jack Gray at Roof Observations. That's the dimensional convention. Hardwood is sold rough by the board foot with its own surfacing conventions, like that 13/16 cherry. Don't mix the two tables up.
Ask Before You Buy
So what do you do with all this? Before you hand over a card, ask three questions. Is this net or gross tally? Is the price based on rough thickness, and is anything in the bin skip planed? And what does milling cost, per foot, and does the footage get re-tallied after?
Then take the price you were quoted and add your waste. A $5 board foot that loses 10% to milling is not a $5 board foot. It never was.
That guy at the counter? Wengert says his board was 9 board feet. The yard billed 10.6. That's not a rounding error. That's a foot and a half of wood he paid for and never got.